|
|
News of the River
"all of the river news all of the time"
September 1999 to February 2000
Spawning Recruitment Study: UPDATE
February 8, 2000
by Dr. Ian Martin
On November 30 brown trout eggs from OMNR's Normandale
Hatchery were successfully placed into the Grand River,
Swan and Carroll Creeks, and into bell jars which act as
minihatcheries (see an earlier article "FOGR
Study on Spawning Success is Underway"). Since
then there has been a bit of breathing space as eggs developed
towards hatching and the experiment progressed.The eggs
in a bell jar at the GRCA monitoring station at Belwood
all died about 2 weeks after they were placed in this mini-hatchery
which uses water pumped from the river. It seems that a
combination of caddisflies and silt clogged up the valve,
shutting off water flow to the bell jar and so the eggs
died from lack of oxygen. The clogging problem has been
solved by a minor plumbing change, so that if we attempt
this part of the experiment again, water flow should not
be a problem. We live and learn, and thank GRCA for allowing
access to this very useful facility.Eggs in the bell jars
supplied with well water flourished. Since the well water
is a constant 7 degrees, the eggs developed more rapidly
in this experimental control hatchery than in the river
water which has mostly been in the 0-2 degree range. Eggs
in both of the well-water jars hatched a bit before Christmas
with pretty good success rates, and we now have close to
2000 tiny trout swimming around a large shallow tray. Initially,
the newly hatched alevins fed on their attached yolk sacs,
but in the past couple of weeks they have completely resorbed
the contents of the yolk sacs and are now being regularly
fed with a standard commercial starter food, courtesy of
the fish research station near Alma. This well-water setup
is an experimental control, to give us an idea of mortality
rates that we might expect under ideal conditions. These
numbers can then be compared to mortality in eggs reared
in river-water bell jars (next year?) or in the Scotty boxes
in the river.
|
|
Fresh Fry!
The fry from the Normandale Hatchery hatched very quickly.
|
|
Click on the picture for a bigger image
|
Without the presence of the Belwood bell-jar hatchery to tell
us when to expect hatching in the Scotty boxes, we had to dig
up a few Scotty boxes to check on egg development or hatching.
This was done on 05 January, and no hatching had yet taken place
in the sample Scotty boxes from either the upper river station
near Belwood, or the lower river station between County Road
86 and the closed bridge concession. The good news is that both
stations had only nominal mortality of eggs: 1 or 2 eggs out
of 130 in each Scotty box. Boxes from the upper river station
had egg cells nearly clogged with organic silt, but the eggs
were still viable. Boxes from the lower river were nearly lost
owing to scour and anchor ice, even though they had been covered
by fairly large stones. However, organic silt was less evident
inside the cells of the boxes from this lower station. We elected
not to disturb boxes at the middle river station since development
should be similar to that noted at the other stations. Boxes
checked at the upper and lower river stations were reburied
in their original locations and we anticipate checking these,
the middle river boxes, and those from Swan and Carroll Creeks,
before mid-February. Right now, most of the river is covered
in ice, though less so than a week ago. The forecast spell of
mild weather should give us a window to get at the boxes next
week. Stay tuned!Excavation of marked, natural redds in the
river to collect dead or live eggs should occur in late March
or earlier, when permits are issued by DFO.
New Training for Fish and Wildlife
Guardians
by Jeff Prickett
In mid-January, members of Friends of the Grand River attended
the first training seminar for the new Provincial Fish and
Wildlife Guardian Programme. This programme builds upon the
popular and successful River Watch Programme pioneered by
our group, which was so well received by OMNR that the concept
has been formalized and extended to wildlife guardianship
as well. Those interested in becoming Guardians take part
in a 2-day training seminar conducted by one of the provincial
Master Guardians, who themselves have taken extensive training
from MNR staff.The first 2-day course was conducted by our
own local Master Guardian and ex-President of FOGR, Ken Collins.
Brad Gerrie, the OMNR Enforcement Supervisor from the Guelph
District Office, was there as well, as an additional resource
for training sessions. The venue for the course was the Belwood
office of the GRCA, and seven trainees were in attendance.The
course was intensive, covering everything from an introduction
to provincial law, observation techniques, and of course the
provincial Fish and Wildlife Act. At the conclusion of the
second day, a short quiz was written by those attending. This
was marked during the following week by the two instructors.
Our thanks go out to Ken and to Brad, for an informative and
well-run training session. Ken has advised that another training
course will be conducted in the early spring. Watch this space
for details!There have been some questions from FOGR members
about the status of our River Watch following the introduction
of this new provincial programme, so here's how things work.
You can still participate in the River Watch programme if
you are unable to attend the Guardian Programme training session.
River Watch is not dead. If you are interested in either River
Watch OR Fish and Wildlife Guardian Programmes, contact me,
Jeff Prickett for more details. (Jeff is the contact for FOGR
participation; Ken Collins has a wider responsibility: he
has to train Guardians all over southwestern Ontario for all
interested groups.)I look forward to hearing from anyone with
questions or comments about the Fish and Wildlife Guardian
Programme, or with River Watch. Remember, spring is just around
the corner, and soon our beloved Grand River will again come
alive with anglers of all sorts. It's our duty to make sure
that everyone knows the special regulations and areas, in
addition to the normal regulations and areas.The stewardship
of the Grand River has been placed upon us, and it's a responsibility
that we take seriously.
Jeff Prickett,
FOGR contact for Fish & Wildlife Guardian Programme and
for River Watch.
406 William St.
Cambridge, Ont.
N3H 3W5
phone 519-653-0084
FOGR Study on Spawning Success is Underway!
December 4, 1999
Early on Weds. 01 December, 1999 FOGR volunteer Jeff Prickett
picked up 7500 fertilized brown trout eggs from the OMNR Normandale
Hatchery near Turkey Point, thans to arrangements worked out
by Daryl Coulson of the Guelph OMNR office. Another 11 volunteers
helped count and load the eggs into Scotty Egg Incubator boxes,
which were then placed into the main river at three locations:
one each in the lower, middle, and upper sections of the river.
 |
 |
| Swan Feathers were used to put one egg into
each of the cells in the Scotty Box |
The boxes were buried in areas of known spawning
activity. Larry "Cool Hand" McGratton is shown
with the box just before burying. |
|
Click on the image to see a full size picture
|
Additional boxes were incubated in Swan and Carroll Creeks.
As well, three bell-jar incubators were set up with about 1300
eggs each. These bell jars are supplied with either river water
or well water, depending on location.
|
|
|
| Some eggs are being incubated in bell jars
to see the effect of pure water on Grand River trout eggs |
Eggs from the Normandale hatchery are also being
raised in Grand River water. |
|
Click on the image to see a full size picture
|
GRCA also has been an enthusiastic supporter of this effort,
and has provided a safe and secure location for rearing eggs
on pumped water from the upper Grand. Natural redds also were
marked in the river, so that fisheries biologist Derek Parks
(University of Waterloo) can locate them for further studies
through the winter. The object of the exercise, rather than
just rearing fish, is also to determine whether natural spawning
trout have any likelihood of success. Almost 500 redds of
brown trout were mapped in the 06 November, 1999 survey, yet
we do not know if any offspring result from this spawning.
Derek Parks will be making comparisons of hatching success
between eggs excavated from natural redds, eggs in Scotty
boxes in the Grand, Swan, and Carroll, and eggs reared in
stream or well water. Results from these comparisons should
help OMNR, GRCA, and FOGR determine how best to help the spawning
trout of the Grand to produce the maximum number of young
trout.Many thanks to all the volunteers who turned out on
a cold day to swing pickaxes and swan's feathers in FOGR's
cooperative effort with OMNR and GRCA!
Dr. Ian Martin
Half Empty or Half Full?
November 23, 1999
The Beatty Dam continues to be in the Elora and Fergus news.
The Beatty Dam was drained and refilled earlier this year
(see
an earlier article). Friends of the Grand River has taken
photos of the dam and in its drained and undrained state.
It is clear that head pond shown drained on the top and full
on the bottom has almost no silt and, if the dam is removed,
cobble and gravel will be exposed.
The Head Pond of Beatty Dam
 |
October 7, 1999
November 22, 1999
|
| Dr. Ian Martin Photo, click on
images to expand to full size picture |
Fall Gathering of the Friends
of the Grand River
The fall gathering is a meeting were the board of Friends
of the Grand River will address your concerns, questions and
suggestions. The format of this meeting is open floor so if
you have praise or complaints, this is the time and place
for them.On Sunday November 28, 1999 from 2:00-4:30 the fall
gathering meeting will take place at the Wellington Terrace
Home for the Aged in Elora. Its located on Cuthbert Street
just off of Colborne Street in Elora. To find Colborne Street,
drive down the main street of Elora, until you see the post
office and municipal building, turn on to Colborne Street
and head east to Cuthbert Street, turn left and drive to the
end of the street and your there.For more information contact
Larry R. McGratton at 519-843-3102
First Pictures of the "Dry"
Beatty Dam
Nov. 18, 1999
The Beatty Dam in Fergus slowly lost
its water
in September and October due to structural decay.
 |
| To the surprise of most, the draining of the
head pond revealed gravel and cobble not silt
and shopping carts. Click on the thumbnail pictures
to see the full size pictures.Click on the links
for more on the Beatty Dam emptying
and then refilled. |
|
 |
 |
Successful Redd Count HeldNov. 6, 1999The Friends of the Grand
River were out in numbers this Saturday at 8 AM counting spawning
redds from Zuber's Corners (Highway 86) right to the Shand Dam.
Many miles of river were carefully surveyed for evidence of
spawning trout by a dozen or so volunteers wading every inch
of the fast running river. Hundreds of redds were spotted and
carefully recorded on topographical maps of the river.This survey
was carried out on behalf of the Grand River Conservation Authority
(GRCA) and Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources (OMNR) who
hope to use the data to indicate fish numbers and possible sites
for habitat improvement. Perhaps this will be the year we discover
why with so many eager trout we have so little success recruiting
trout into the population.
Spawning Success in the Grand
October 27, 1999
Photo courtesy of Ian Martin. (click on image
for full size picture) Another year and another attempt at
spawning by the brown trout of the Grand River. From Belwood
to Zuber's Corners the trout are cutting redds and laying
eggs.So far not much recruitment of fish has been shown but
the trout have certainly given it there all once again. It
is not clear why the eggs fail to hatch but we at Friends
of the Grand River are trying to be part of the solution by
counting redds and improving water quality.
The Beatty Dam Refills- Grand River Dewatered!
Saturday, October 9, 1999
Owing to natural deterioration, generalized leakage, and
collapse of the main centre gate, the Beatty Dam in Fergus
steadily lost storage capacity through much of September and
October. By the evening of Thursday, 07 October, 1999 the
dam was drawn down approximately 90% of storage capacity,
showing a vertical drop of more than 1.5 meters (5 feet).
Cobble and gravel riffles and runs, showing a productive,
medium gradient channel were clearly visible in the reclaimed
stream bed above the Hwy. 6 bridge. Less than 1 meter water
depth was retained behind the dam. Friends of the Grand River
(FOGR) has abundant photographic documentation of these conditions.Through
most of the day on Friday, 08 October, 1999 flow in the river
below the dam was greatly curtailed and spawning riffles in
the river below the abandoned rail trestle were entirely dewatered.
Brown trout had already begun some spawning excavations in
these areas. Also a consideration is that treated effluent
from the Fergus and Elora sewage treatment plants may not
be adequately diluted by these low flows, so that water quality
could be impaired by heightened concentrations of chlorine
and nutrients.As of 10 am on Saturday, 09 October, 1999 the
Beatty dam is completely refilled and is water is flowing
over the lip of the structure. At 11:30 am this same date,
FOGR executive members living in the area (Larry McGratton,
Ian Martin, and Ken Collins) inspected the Beatty dam to determine
why the structure refilled so rapidly (river flows into the
dam have been relatively constant). Water turbidity precluded
inspection above the dam. Ken Collins inspected the structure
from underneath. He found it difficult to approach the newly
closed centre gate because of turbulent discharge through
the rotting wood of the dam decking, but it appeared that
the gate had been covered by lumber and wood debris, possibly
including some plywood sheeting. He also noted that several
of the main support beams, originally 12-by-12 inch timbers,
have rotted and eroded away to dimensions of approximately
2-by-2 inches. FOGR has documented these conditions with further
photographs.We (FOGR) have reported these events to DFO, OMNR,
and GRCA in light of their possible effects on the spawning
activities of brown trout and other autumn spawning fish species,
and the recent communications of DFO with the council of Centre
Wellington through their engineers (Dale Murray, Triton),
regarding application for refilling of the Beatty dam after
drainage. It also appears to us that the dam may be a threat
to public safety in its refilled state. FOGR also has been
in communication with Mayor Pinkney of Centre Wellington,
who stated that council has not authorized any repair work
to the Beatty dam.Ian Martin 10/13/99
The Beatty Dam Empties- Prime Trout
Habitat Created
September 28, 1999
News Release from Friends of the Grand RiverThe federal Department
of Fisheries and Oceans has scotched plans by the Township
of Centre Wellington to drain and refill the Beatty Dam in
downtown Fergus, reports the Fergus-Elora News Express (22
September, 1999). Triton, the town's engineering firm had
proposed drainage of the dam in order to inspect the structure
and allow a more accurate costing of the options of repair,
replacement, or removal of the dam, which appears to be in
an advanced state of deterioration. DFO indicated that drainage
of the dam was not a problem, but that refilling or, presumably,
replacement, would go against their policy which "strongly
supports the rehabilitation projects that endeavor to restore
previously altered aquatic habitats to their more natural
state."At present, the Beatty dam, which was built to
supply power, is not a working operation. It is a replacement
of the original structure and is only about 50 years old.
Local debate on the value of the dam hinges on aesthetic considerations:
some believe it to be a tourist attraction, while others believe
that the dam has a negative impact on what would otherwise
be an attractive, natural river valley.Despite dissenting
opinion from Ontario's Ministry of Natural Resources, Triton
Engineering stands by its claim that removal of the dam will
cost the municipality $100,000 more than replacement of the
structure, for a total budget of $374,000, owing to anticipated
costs of rehabilitation of the riverbed behind and under the
dam. Triton has previously worked with the Beatty dam in 1996,
when it carried out ad hoc repairs to the existing structure.
These repairs resulted in short-term water deprivation downstream,
threatening fish and other aquatic life, and failing to adequately
dilute treated sewage effluent. After being informed of the
DFO response by Dale Murray of Triton, Township council agreed
to have Quaile Engineering assess the safety of the existing
structure and determine costs for a visual concept of an undammed
river profile.
Back to the Friends of the
Grand Homepage
Didn't find it here? Go to the
news archives
|